Toyota Corolla the cheapest small car to repair

Steane Klose | Feb 7, 2008

According to NRMA Insurance, the Toyota Corolla costs less to repair after a low-speed crash than its main small car rivals. The NRMA used the ‘bumper test’ to make the collision cost assessment. The bumper test simulates a 10km/h collision which, according to the NRMA is the most common type of road crash.

The most notable result of the small car bumper test conducted by the NRMA was that the Corolla cost at least half as much to repair as any of the other eight cars tested. The NRMA noted that the Corolla was evidence that manufacturers could design vehicles that performed well in both pedestrian safety and vehicle protection.

After the test on nine small and compact cars, NRMA Insurance estimated the Corolla would cost just $1,019 to repair, equivalent to 4.4 per cent of its purchase price.

Repair costs for the other vehicles tested were all above 10 per cent of their purchase prices - and two were over 30 per cent, with the new Mitsubishi Lancer and Suzuki Swift costing more than $5,000 to repair. Honda's Civic was a standout, with the repair bill coming in at a staggering $7,386 or in excess of 30 percent of the replacement value of the car.

The low-speed crash testing highlighted the fact that a car's bumper design had a big impact on the amount of damage caused in low-speed collisions and specific design enhancements - even those unnoticed by owners - could have a sizeable impact on the cost of insurance.

The results of the low-speed crash testing were as follows.

Vehicle

Repair cost

Repair cost as % of RRP

Toyota Corolla (5-door hatch)

$1,019

4.4%

Ford Focus (sedan)

$2,358

10.7%

Holden Astra (5-door hatch)

$2,627

10.9%

Mazda3 (5-door hatch)

$2,886

12.6%

Toyota Yaris (5-door hatch)

$4,016

22.1%

Hyundai Getz (5-door hatch)

$3,363

22.4%

Mitsubishi Lancer (sedan)

$5,467

23.5%

Honda Civic (sedan)

$7,386

31.0%

Suzuki Swift (5-door hatch)

$5,547

34.7%

Follow Steane Klose on Google+

Filed under: Hyundai, Honda, Safety, Holden, Toyota, Mitsubishi, Suzuki, swift, Mazda, accord, focus, Lancer, mitsubishi lancer, EV, Civic, mazda3, yaris, crash, corolla, Toyota Corolla, MG, rs, testing, crash test, is, ve, US, a3, ss, prices, sedan, hatch, ti, astra, News, new, price, getz, z, sti, TT, motor, i, x, car, design, fr, cars, tl, ring, ice, report, g, UK, rrp, note, top, air, black, mitsu, compact car, 62, Hyunda, enthusiast

Leave a comment:

Required
Required
Enter comment here.
  • poo says,
    6 years ago
    Yeah but its a girls car ay
  • Shaun says,
    5 years ago
    Maybe it is a girl's car, but i've had one since they released the latest model in '07, and its sure made me never want to buy another large car with chrome bits tacked on. The plastic underneath is pretty useless as our 1km dirt driveway can get a bit hairy when rain washes it out, but its been held up by zip ties put there by the local toyota repair team and was said to be 'temporary'. That was in september 07. Was backed into by a falcon a few months ago and it only cost them $300 to fix up the door panel. Its well thought out and really chuckable through windy roads. I love it.

advertisement